US Player Ratings for USA vs. Japan World Cup Final

2011 July 17
by Jerrod Roh

United States Drops Heartbreaker to Japan in Final

Writer Jerrod Roh has provided coverage, analysis, and opinion for the 2011 Women’s World Cup for IMSoccer News. He has attended the last 3 men’s World Cups in South Korea, Germany, and South Africa as well as the 2003 Women’s World Cup in the U.S. He is a self-described fan, student, and teacher of the game.

Report Card

Hope Solo – GK – B – There was not much more Hope could have done. The Japanese goals were manufactured by testing our central defense as often as possible. I just wonder if she could have been coming out a bit for a ball that was crossed low at the 6’ on the first goal.  If she did, then she would have been closer to the initial muffed clearance attempt, and perhaps then could have called “Keeper” and dove in to clean up the mess. On the 2nd goal against, she seemed to be a little screened by Lloyd, making it difficult to see the quick redirect by Sawa for the dramatic extra time goal for Japan. Very difficult to fault Hope on either goal though. She was solid again, but just did not come up with the great reflex save needed for the U.S. to win.

Christie Rampone – CB – C plus – The Japanese placed their two strikers squarely on our two center backs and once their team as a whole saw more possession as the match wore on, chances to play into spaces around our central defenders were more prevalent. Rampone was solid, but not the rock that we needed her to be. She buckled a couple times under the Japanese pressure.

Rachel Buehler – CB – D plus – Rachel was strong in the tackle like she usually is. But her muffed clearance attempt led to the first Japanese goal.  It was an unfortunate sequence to say the least. Credit Japan for playing balls in that were tough to defend. Could she have just passed the ball out for a corner kick instead of trying to clear in traffic so close to her own goal? The bigger breakdown on Rachel’s part though happened when she failed to honor Japan’s best player – Sawa – by trailing her across the box on the corner kick which led to the game-tying goal in extra time to send the match to PKs. Granted, Sawa finished from an improbable angle, but if Rachel’s bread and butter is her physical strength, then why is she not using it to throw Sawa off of her run a bit there in extra time?

Ali Krieger – RB – B minus – Ali played well.  Our wide backs both did well to help with the possession advantage we owned in the first half especially.  One just has to wonder if our wide backs covered our center backs enough when we were holding a goal advantage with little time remaining given the intent on the Japanese to isolate our center backs. As the match wore on, Ali’s ability to connect and help in the attack faded.

Amy LePeilbet – LB – B – Similar to Ali, but gave a bit more in the attack and stepped out to disrupt Japanese possession a few more times in the first half from her more forward position. After starting the tournament out as a question mark, Amy played her way through some shaky times to be a real strength on this team.

Carli Lloyd – CMF – B – I was proud of Carli. I thought she really stepped up to help destroy any attempt the Japanese had at creating an attacking rhythm. She was more mobile and dangerous in the attack than she has been in awhile. I thought she shared the ball well in the attacking end. She just lacked the finishing touch and hit a couple off balance shots again.

Shannon Boxx – CMF – B – Boxxy was an equally effective destroyer and the Japanese really had a difficult time against her and Lloyd. Japan’s best player and leader, Sawa, was neutralized for the majority of the match by Boxxy and co. This really allowed the U.S. to dictate the match. We just could not finish enough of our chances.

Heather O’Reilly – RMF – B plus – Heather was a warrior once again.  The Japanese always tried to have 2 defenders deal with Heather when she was faced up out wide. It seemed to work for Japan, but Heather still got off some quality service and generated a couple of shots worthy of taking. Her shots just did not find the frame this match. Heather did a lot of defensive work as usual. For the most part, she neutralized the Japanese left back who liked to run forward frequently and is known for her attacking.

Megan Rapinoe – LMF – A minus – Megan was a real joy to watch this tournament, especially in the knockout round. She assisted on the first U.S. goal with a great long ball that caught the Japanese back line snoozing. The only thing missing for Megan was finishing one of her opportunities at goal or finding that goal-scoring cross that we now expect from her.

Abby Wambach – F – A minus – Abby scored another great goal of course, but it was her work off of Cheney in the first half and Morgan in the 2nd and extra time that really makes you appreciate her efforts. Abby is a much smarter player that she was even five years ago. She reads the game and her partner up top better now. Her outward leadership and courage makes you wonder if she should be wearing the captain’s band instead of Rampone sometimes. She was unlucky to not score more than once against Japan. Clearly, we needed her to. Abby was a big part of disrupting the Japanese possession as she would often come to a lower position to neutralize Japan’s defensive midfield player.

Lauren Cheney – F – B – Lauren was dangerous and caused havoc for Japan in the first half with her mobility up top. It would have been nice to see her execute around the goal better. I think most Americans felt unfortunate to not be up 2-0 at the half. This has to fall on the whole team, but Cheney put herself in some great spots around the goal, and now she just has find that finishing touch whether with the shot or pass. Her patience on the endline to continue on until Rapinoe was able to get into a goal-scoring seam was great. We just needed a couple more moments like that from Lauren. In her defense, she apparently was hampered by injury and subbed at the half. Overall solid work from Lauren again.

Alex Morgan – F – A plus – The team calls Alex “Young Horse” because of how she looks when she runs. I guess they think her legs kind of go all over the place. Well, whatever she is doing seems to work. She certainly can cover the ground and outrun world class defenders. The Japanese back line is very well organized, especially when they are forced to entrench in their half. Alex of course gave U.S. fans great excitement and hope with a goal and an assist in this thrilling match. Look for her to be even better in London next summer at the Olympics. It is clear to me that she needs to be on the field for longer than just 20 minutes in a substitute role. Dare I state that I think it is now clear to her coaches and U.S. teammates too?  She may very well be the top striker in the world come 2015 in Canada.

Tobin Heath – LMF – C – Tobin came on late for Rapinoe and nearly won the match when a free kick was pinballed to her for her chance for glory. A Japanese defender was able to slide in and block her ensuing shot. Coming on so late, Tobin either needs to finish that chance or convert her penalty and she did neither. I like Tobin as a player. Right now though when she takes defenders on, she is lacking the bigger touch to push it past them. Either that or she is waiting too long to play that touch to beat the defender and getting stuffed. Her timing is off. In this World Cup, Tobin failed to produce in 1v1s like she is capable of. Hopefully she will get it sorted and be ready to show her attacking skill in the Olympics.

Jerrod Roh

Jerrod Roh has served as an assistant coach for the University of Minnesota Golden Gophers Women’s Soccer Team since 2007. He’s also served as a Goalkeeping Staff coach for the US Soccer Region 2 ODP since 2005. Prior to coming to Minnesota, Roh spent three seasons at the University of Kentucky, serving as the top assistant while coaching the goalkeepers and serving as the program’s recruiting coordinator. Roh attended Kansas State University and graduated in 1995. He was a three-year starter for the Wildcats. He holds a masters in business administration from Western Carolina. Currently he is coaching the U15 girls team for Eden Prairie Soccer Club.

8 Responses
  1. Richard permalink
    July 18, 2011

    Overall I thought this was the best game the US played in the entire tournament. Except for the outcome (from a US fan perspective) it was a great final to watch. After Becky S performance against France, I thought it would have been obvious to start her or at least sub her in based on the high attack by Japan. Rachel B just doesn’t have the pace. I agree that Hope was curiously passive in goal, perhaps they knew something about Japan that we don’t know. I think the C- is a bit harsh for Rampone considering the extended role she was asked to fulfill.

  2. Kara permalink
    July 18, 2011

    I think they call Morgan “Baby Horse.” i think Rampone gets a higher grade than Kriger. Heath lacks any intensity in her game and is hard to watch. Not sure about such a high grade for her. More like a C-.

  3. July 18, 2011

    One glaring grade adjustment needs to be made and one ommision:

    1. Tobin Heath was closer to a D- than a C….she came in and immediately turned the ball over to Japan on 3 straight possesions and played a soft, unfocused game the rest of the way, and her PK was a very weak effort.

    2. You also failed to grade Coach Pia Sundhage (C-) who IMO was at fault for the PK lineup. Boxx in the line-up again??!! are you kidding me? she missed her first kick against Brazil and and then barely made her second. She has a transparent and predicatble move during PK’s and should NOT have been in that situation again. Why was Alex Morgan not in there? She has an accurate and overpowering kick that is perfect for PK’s and she was also very focused.

    Overall, you are spot-on with the other players.
    Excellent article

  4. July 18, 2011

    Jroh-

    AWESOME work on all the articles! You really have a gift for writing and I love your insight and analysis the last few weeks.

    I loved the fact we started in a 4-5-1. Loved the adjustment of having Cheney help out the mids as a withdrawn forward. Loved that we got Rapinoe on the field for longer.
    Sauerbrunn starting over Buehler should have been a no-brainer, would rather have seen Lori Lindsey in for Lloyd as she connect passes and had others to carry the load for her in terms of covering ground in a 4-5-1…and Boxx naturally does better as a DCM with 2 ahead of her.

    I was impressed with many of Pia’s adjustments and general player management throughout the tournament but the line-up of shooters is beyond me as was the Heath-Rapinoe sub (did I miss something?)
    Why Boxx. LLoyd. Heath? This drives me nuts. Why not Rampone. OReilly. Morgan? Lloyd’s shot is still coming down from outerspace along with the 20 other ones she put up there during the tournament.

    Nonetheless…the game is so much easier from stands/living room. The last game was by far the best soccer by the US which is a credit to players and coaches. What a World Cup, if it gets more players dreaming of playing at that level one day, more coaches thinking about how to make positive impacts on their players, and more fans excited about the game it was a success. Japan was VERY derserving as they were a hard working, technically talented, tactically savy side, and 100% pure class.

    2015 in Canada should be fun. Hopefully (no pun intended) Solo makes it back for 1 more chance, we have time to develop some backs and CMs who can play a bit more…and Rampinoe/Cheney/Morgan continue to marinate into the most lethal 3-player combination on the planet.

  5. soccerballer17 permalink
    July 18, 2011

    Lloyd with a B grade? She had an absolute shocker from the start. If Cheney did not get hurt, Lloyd would have been subbed out and Cheney moved central and the game woud have been ours. Lloyd tries to turn out of the midfield when she has no business turning. Plays the ball back to her defenders and puts them in horrible situations, and can never put a shot on goal. With a game like that she did not belong in the top 5 for penalties. Not to mention, couldn’t hit the target, yet again, on the last play of the game. . . . And giving Tobin a C is a bit harsh. She drew the foul that should have won the World Cup. Her penalty was lacking, but so was everyone else that missed…. All in all the US did really well to get to the Final and deserved to win, but threw it away, some how, threw it away. But the youth of this squad makes the future look very good!

  6. July 19, 2011

    Too high for Lloyd. Have to deduct at least one grade for that PK horror. And she often looked selfish trying to blast long shots rather than set up plays.

    Krieger played pretty well, but that nightmare sequence with Buehler brings the grade down lower, IMHO.

    Glad you graded Rapinoe high. She played with a looseness and joy in this WWC that was huge. Note the difference in her versus Heath, who looked like she didn’t want to be there.

    Sundhage – high marks for all games but this one! Would rather have seen Sauerbrunn instead of Buehler, and the PK lineup was mindboggling. Shannon Boxx to start? Really? Lloyd and Heath? Why not come out guns blazing with Wambach and Morgan . . . put the pressure on Japan. You don’t save your best for last. As we saw, by the time Wambach got her chance – and nailed it – it was too late.

  7. July 19, 2011

    BTW I agree with Morgan’s A+ score. What more does she have to do to earn playing a whole game?

  8. rick sewall permalink
    July 19, 2011

    Solo has a strong leg on goal kicks,but if she ever learned correct kicking technique her kicks would go 10 to 15 yards further. Also, too many shots over the crossbar because of bad technique. Who on the team teaches kicking? Obviously, noone. I could if asked, no kidding.

Comments are closed.